Xactly vs. Spiff

Go beyond basic commission tracking with scalable enterprise-grade incentive compensation, reporting software, AI forecasting tools, and revenue intelligence.

(Not a “free” tool you’ll quickly outgrow)

Dump the other Guys!
Robo header banner
Read Our G2 Reviews

The people at Xactly, to be honest — whether it’s my CSM, my TAM, or anyone I interact with — are incredibly nice and easy to work with. Of course, the product is great too, but it’s the people who make the product truly exceptional. When you have a great experience alongside a great product, it really enhances everything. That’s what I love about our partnership with Xactly. In fact, I consider my CSM and TAM to be an extension of my team.

Xactly allows us to scale and motivate our reps properly no matter how much or fast we grow.

If you’re still doing work on Excel or homegrown, I would highly encourage you to look at an automated system. Not only will you have better reporting and analytics to understand where you are spending your money, but it will definitely help with the work-life-balance. Compensation is pretty complicated. You have people coming, you have people going, you’ve got quotas changing, people getting promoted…you need to have a system of record to manage all that. If you are doing it homegrown or you are doing it [by] managing it manually, it is going to get to the point where the scalability is not there. 

Whiteboard
xactly-logo
SPIFF
ScalabilityComposable, flexible, built to scale (with a proven track record)A limited tool (risky!)
Enterprise Readiness & GovernanceAudited, enterprise-grade governance and complianceLacks proven governance maturity (unproven & unchecked)
Implementation & IntegrationRobust, pre-built connector that integrateS with Salesforce and major HRIS/ERP systemsA standalone acquisition with integrations that demand custom, time-heavy builds
Testing & MitigationPrevents payroll risk by isolating testing from live environments = a smart choiceHigher risk of payroll errors and rep mistrust Boooooooo!
Feature Robo

When commissions can’t fail, enterprise teams choose Xactly, the proven Sales Performance Management platform with over 20 years of leadership. Purpose-built for complex, global incentive compensation, Xactly delivers trusted accuracy, faster financial close, and AI-powered insights that power confident decisions across the entire revenue lifecycle.

= more $$ for you and your team

Robot arm image
X>S

Awards & Recognition

Why companies choose Xactly over Spiff

Tick Icon

Audit Readiness

Xactly delivers enterprise-grade sales compensation compliance, audit trails, and financial controls that go beyond what Spiff offers, making it the trusted choice for SOX-ready organizations.

Tick Icon

Payroll Confidence

Companies choose Xactly’s enterprise incentive compensation management software to ensure accurate commission payouts and eliminate payroll corrections.

Tick Icon

Lower Risk Operations

Real-time commission visibility and transparent calculations reduce disputes and operational risk as organizations outgrow simpler compensation tools.

Tick Icon

Enterprise Proven

Xactly is purpose-built and proven for enterprise sales performance management, unlike Spiff, which originated as a mid-market solution.

Tick Icon

Growth Readiness

Organizations that start with Spiff often move to Xactly as growth introduces complex compensation plans and enterprise scale requirements.

Tick Icon

True SPM Platform

Xactly is a dedicated, end-to-end Sales Performance Management platform, not an add-on, giving enterprises a system of record they can grow into.

Tick Icon

Platform Flexibility

Xactly integrates deeply with Salesforce without lock-in, preserving flexibility as business and technology needs evolve.

Tick Icon

Enterprise Safeguards

Built-in validation and testing capabilities protect commission accuracy and prevent live-production errors at scale.

Tick Icon

Innovation and Leadership

Xactly continues to innovate across incentive compensation, forecasting, and revenue intelligence, while Spiff is focused on Salesforce platform migration.

Xactly’s numbers don’t lie.

90
%
Average reduction in overpayments.
Forrester Study
99.8
%
On-time commission payment accuracy.
Xactly Benchmarking Data
60
%
LESS time needed to create compensation plans.
Forrester Study

Xactly Is Built for Accuracy, Scale, and Control

salesforce-native-myth

The Salesforce-Native Myth

Spiff customers often learn too late that Salesforce-native introduces more complexity than clarity. Separate data models, middleware dependencies like MuleSoft or Workato, and dual systems of record increase implementation risk and weaken commission accuracy. Xactly is the market’s only truly Salesforce-native incentive compensation management platform built for enterprise scale, delivering compliance, control, and flexibility without platform lock-in.

Confidence, not chaos

Xactly Incent is enterprise incentive compensation management software built for complex plans, quotas, and hierarchies, and sales performance incentive funds, so commissions stay accurate and audit-ready. Sales, Finance, and HR get real-time visibility they can trust, backed by automation and enterprise controls. With Xactly, you can leave spreadsheets behind and rely on a true system of record for revenue.

confidence-not-chaos

1200+ Customers Globally Trust Xactly to Make Their Sales Make Sense

Salesforce Logo
LinkedIn logo
Flowserve Logo
Hyatt logo
Baker Hughes Logo
DocuSign logo
Pendo logo

Frequently Asked Questions

What is incentive compensation management (ICM) software?

Incentive compensation management (ICM) software automates the calculation, validation, and payment of sales commissions using governed rules and auditable logic. Enterprise ICM platforms like Xactly support complex compensation plans, global sales teams, and compliance requirements that spreadsheets and lightweight tools cannot scale to.

What does SPM mean in sales and finance?

Sales Performance Management (SPM) is software that helps organizations plan, manage, and optimize sales performance by connecting compensation, quotas, forecasting, and analytics. Xactly’s enterprise SPM platform serves as a system of record for revenue, aligning sales, finance, HR, and RevOps.

How do companies automate sales commissions?

Companies automate sales commissions by using incentive compensation management (ICM) software that replaces spreadsheets with automated calculations, validation rules, and audit trails. Enterprise platforms like Xactly integrate with CRM and financial systems to ensure accurate, compliant, and scalable commission processing as complexity grows.

Is Xactly a good alternative to Spiff?

Xactly is a leading Spiff alternative for mid-market and enterprise organizations that need accurate, compliant, and scalable commission management. While Spiff focuses on simple commission visibility, Xactly delivers enterprise-grade incentive compensation, governance, forecasting, and analytics.

Is Spiff enterprise-ready?

No. Spiff was designed for mid-market use cases and is limited for enterprise environments with complex compensation plans, global sales teams, and audit requirements. Xactly is purpose-built and proven for enterprise-scale sales performance management.

Does Xactly ensure commission compliance and audit readiness?

Yes. Xactly is built for sales compensation compliance, offering audit trails, controlled calculation logic, and SOX-ready governance. This ensures commission accuracy and reduces audit risk for finance and compliance teams.

What happens when commission complexity increases?

As commission complexity increases, spreadsheet-based or lightweight tools introduce errors, delays, and audit risk. Enterprise platforms like Xactly are designed to manage complex plans, hierarchies, and global requirements without sacrificing accuracy.

Xactly Is Built for Every Team That Owns Commissions

Currency Circle Dollar Icon

Finance

Finance teams use Xactly for commission accuracy, audit-ready controls, and faster close cycles. Built-in governance and SPM-driven forecasting reduce risk and eliminate spreadsheets.

handshake

Sales Operations / RevOps

Xactly provides a scalable sales compensation platform built for complex plans and growth. Advanced modeling enables rapid changes as territories, quotas, and incentives evolve.

icon-park

Sales Leadership

Xactly gives sales leaders real-time commission visibility and performance dashboards they can trust. Accurate incentives drive attainment without disputes or surprises.

HR

HR

Xactly supports sales compensation compliance, governance, and pay equity analytics. Enterprise-grade controls ensure fair, transparent programs that scale globally.

Xactly: 20+ Years Leading Sales Performance Management

Xactly is the original innovator in Sales Performance Management (SPM), with more than 20 years of experience supporting enterprise revenue organizations around the world. Driven by data, expertise, and innovation, Xactly is continuously investing in advancing the SPM category through: Data-driven research and benchmarks on sales compensation, quota attainment, and performance trends Educational webinars and virtual events for sales, finance, HR, and RevOps leaders Expert-led podcasts and thought leadership on modern revenue operations and forecasting Best-practice guidance aligned to enterprise governance, compliance, and financial controls As your organization grows, Xactly is built to support your success. Connect with our team to request a demo or speak to one of our experts to see how Xactly can help you simplify commissions, improve forecasting, and move forward with confidence.